How steel roofing compares to other roofing products.

How Steel Roofing Compares to Other Roofing Products

When considering roofing options, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons of various materials. Here’s a breakdown of how steel roofing stacks up against other popular choices:

‍

Asphalt/Composition Shingles

While asphalt shingles are easy to install, they lack the aesthetic appeal of metal roofing. They often blow off in strong winds and typically show wear and tear within 6-12 years. The shift to a fiberglass mat in shingles, post-1998, has led to increased failure rates, particularly in extreme climates. Additionally, asphalt shingles are not recyclable, contributing to landfill waste and making them an unsustainable choice.

‍

Cedar Wood Shakes

Cedar shakes offer natural beauty and character due to their color variations. However, they require ongoing maintenance to prevent issues like insect infestations, mold, and rot. Their lifespan is generally less than that of metal roofing, and they are flammable, often failing to meet fire safety codes, which can lead to higher insurance premiums. Furthermore, old cedar shakes are not recyclable, raising their lifecycle cost.

‍

Slate Tiles

Slate tiles are a premium option, providing a natural look and long lifespan. They are noncombustible and low-maintenance, but can break under foot traffic during maintenance. Their heavy weight necessitates additional roof truss support, making them unsuitable for reroofing projects. While aesthetically appealing, they are expensive and challenging to install.

‍

Concrete Tile

Concrete tiles are a fiber-reinforced cement product designed to be waterproof. However, early versions suffered from durability issues related to freeze and thaw cycles. Though concrete tiles provide good fire and pest protection, they are not recyclable, and their weight poses challenges for installation and removal, making them less favorable compared to the advantages of metal roofing.

‍

Stone-Coated Interlocking Panels

While these panels last longer than asphalt shingles, they can suffer from the separation of stone granules over time, leading to clogging in gutters and downpipes. This "zebra effect" can impair drainage and create additional maintenance concerns.

‍

Stamped/Interlocking Metal Systems

Metal systems designed to mimic the look of cedar shakes or slate are often stamped, which can compromise the steel’s gauge and damage the color coating. Many manufacturers void warranties if the coating is stretched, meaning any warranty given may not be reliable.

‍

The Advantages of Steel Roofing

All metal roofing products are generally superior to the options discussed above, but quality varies. Rudan Roofing’s panels are roll-formed, a gentle process that maintains the integrity of the steel. This method ensures durability and long-term protection, making our metal roofing an excellent choice for homeowners.

‍